When we were little, my parents took us to Pic 'N Save a few days before Christmas (or on Christmas Eve) so we could all buy presents for each other. It was the best night of the year! Because even though we all sort of knew that Pic 'N Save was not the location where everyone else was shopping, we knew we could always find something cool for a dollar. One of my favorite gifts was a yellow baseball-tee my little brother gave to me. It had some sort of cherub/angel/flower on it. I wore it for a couple of years because I thought it was so awesome. And then I threw it away. I've always regretted that choice because somehow, I suspect it would still fit me—it was one of those magical pieces of those clothing that never stops fitting you.
Another favorite was this strawberry porcelain dish I gave my sister. I know this doesn't count because it wasn't gifted to me, but I still think about it—
And, the famous sheep that my oldest brother gave me: